#10. Vanilla Sandwiches – These classic take-anywhere-treats are perfect for a no-fuss indulgence that satisfies any sweet tooth. And a notable mention about these tasty treats, out of all our ice cream, our Vanilla Sandwiches saw the biggest increase in sales in 2021. Looks like people were really craving these sweet sandwiches last year! 

#9. Cookies & Cream – Cookies? Ice Cream? Why not both?! When you can’t decide between cookies or ice cream for a little sweet treat, Cookies & Cream is always the way to go. Fans of this flavor know Cookies & Cream is truly the best of both worlds, so it’s no surprise this flavor came in at #9.

#8. Neapolitan – Why have one when you can have all three? This traditional combination of vanilla, chocolate and strawberry ice cream is perfect for the lover of the classics. Bonus: if you like getting 3 in 1 with Neapolitan, try our Tuxedo flavor: dark chocolate, vanilla and French roast coffee ice cream. 

#7. Cookie Dough – Remember snagging some cookie dough before it went into the oven? Maybe it was when you were a kid… or maybe it was last week. Either way, we’re not judging. Our Cookie Dough ice cream is chunky, cookie dough flavored perfection (no wonder it’s in our top 10). 

#6. Mint-Ting-A-Ling –This one is just so refreshing. Enjoy that taste of cool mint ice cream and swiss chips for an invigoratingly sweet treat (plus, Mint-Ting-A-Ling is fun to say). Also, if you’re a fan of mint ice cream (you’ve got good taste), perhaps give Grasshopper Pie a try: mint ice cream with fudge swirls and crème filled cookie pieces!

#5. Chocolate – Certainly, we all knew this one would be up there, right? Simple and delicious, our signature Chocolate hits the spot when the craving strikes.

#4. Peanut Butter Cup – Chocolate and peanut butter is a match made in our ice cream dreams. This crave-able flavor should be in your freezer at all times.

#3. French Vanilla – A vanilla on the edgier side, our signature French Vanilla is well-loved (as it should be). Try it with cake or pie for a winning celebration.

#2. Panda Paws® – Can we get some applause for the Paws? You loved this one as a kid and you still dig in now. After all, what’s not to love about vanilla ice cream with peanut butter panda paw cups and swirls of thick rich fudge? (P.S. Don’t forget we make Chocolate Panda Paws® too!)

#1. Vanilla – Talk about style and grace, this iconic flavor is anything but run-of-the-mill. Perfect on its own or as an accompaniment to your favorite desserts, this classic is packed with flavor and versatility. And our Vanilla is made with double-fold vanilla extract, for an extra flavorful punch. Of course it’s 2021’s #1!