2024 was a year of twists, turns, and everything in between. No matter where this year took you (or whether you opted for a cone or a dish), you always found your way to a freezer stocked with the Good Stuff! Which flavors had your back (and stomach) this year? The results are in for Perry’s most popular ice cream flavors of 2024!
10. Let’s Dough Buffalo!®
Through chunks of dough and crushed cookies swirled in cookie dough ice cream, your loyalty to your hometown team shined through with every spoonful. If you’re looking for a more portion-friendly option, give our Let’s Dough Buffalo!® Extra Indulgent ice cream bars a try!
9. Cookies & Cream
In 2024, your preferred way of dunking had nothing to do with basketball and everything to do with cookies in milk—a classic choice for a classy ice cream fan. P.S. If crushed cookies are your favorite ice cream inclusion, we recommend adding Cookies & Coffee, Coconut Crush, Doughing, Doughing, Gone!®, Grasshopper Pie, and Let’s Dough Buffalo!® to your 2025 ice cream bucket list.
8. Neapolitan
We admire your taste for nostalgia with this top 10. Plus, why choose one flavor when you can have 3? In 2024, you worked smarter, not harder, and we applaud you for that. Looking for a new trio in 2025? Check out Neapolitan’s sophisticated cousin – Tuxedo: dark chocolate, vanilla and french roast coffee ice cream, all in one carton.
7. Cookie Dough
We’ve all leaned on this star of the ice cream aisle a time or two. It was also our #1 seller in 3-gallon tubs, which shows you can never go wrong with a classic flavor like Cookie Dough. And, if you love a classic chocolate chip cookie and are ready to add a new favorite to your freezer this year, try Cookie Jar!
6. Mint-Ting-A-Ling
In 2024, you decided it was time to refresh and cool down, and we can’t say we blame you. Plus, it’s just as fun to say as it is to eat, and we could all use a little more fun these days.
5. Chocolate
Sometimes, it really is the simple things that make life worth living. You decided smooth, creamy, chocolatey goodness was your journey this year and we love that for you.
4. Peanut Butter Cup
Like Batman & Robin, Mario & Luigi, and Tom & Jerry, chocolate and peanut butter is a classic dynamic duo that stands the test of time—looks like you agree. If peanut butter is your jam, consider scooping up other nutty flavors like Peanut Butter Cookie, Peanut Butter Swirl, and The NutHouse this year!
3. French Vanilla
While you’ve always been a fan of the classics, you exposed a slightly edgier side of your taste with our well-loved French Vanilla. Cest la vie.
2. Panda Paws
It was a wild year, and your flavor preferences were no exception. Keep that wild side going and try this fan-favorite flavor as an extra indulgent bar or pint-sized treat. Looking to branch out more in 2025? Scoop up one of our other varieties of Panda Paws® — just take your pick between Chocolate, Cherry, and Caramel!
1. Vanilla
While some see Vanilla as plain, we see it as infinitely versatile. Great on its own or as the perfect dessert accompaniment, like yourself, Vanilla rolls with the punches and is loved by many. If Vanilla is your favorite but you’re looking for a more indulgent treat, give our Extra Indulgent Madagascar Vanilla a try!
Regardless of how 2024 went for you, we can all agree we’re ready to see what 2025 will bring! Let’s raise a cone to a new year filled with classic flavors you love, new flavors to try, and plenty of Good Stuff to fill your freezer.
Contributor: Mya Priester